top of page

When Is Enough Data Enough?

7 hours ago
3 min read

A Question Every Spine Surgeon and Patient Should Ask

How much evidence does a surgeon need to change?

One publication? Five? Ten?

Or is evidence sometimes not the deciding factor?

After decades as a practicing spine surgeon, I wonder.

We tell patients our decisions are evidence-based.

But how often do we challenge our own preferences?

1. I Refused to Let Others Choose My Technologies

I have always believed patients deserve evidence-based decisions.

Not decisions influenced by a favorite sales representative.

Not loyalty to a distributor or device manufacturer.

Not the pressure to practice like everyone else.

And certainly not financial incentives.

That conviction is why I became a medical technology entrepreneur.

When existing technologies failed to satisfy my clinical vision,

I chose to develop alternatives or acquire promising innovations.

That journey led to KIC Ventures.

I acquired AxioMed to advance motion-preserving disc replacement.

I developed InSpan to investigate less invasive spinal fixation.

I pursued NanoFuse to advance biologic bone regeneration.

These decisions were connected by one clinical philosophy.

Restore function. Diagnose and treat early. Preserve anatomy and motion.

Our REP principles.

I wanted the freedom to investigate better solutions.

And the responsibility to generate evidence supporting their use.

2. InSpan Is Testing an Established Surgical Assumption

Consider low-grade degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis.

Pedicle screws have become an established fixation option.

But are they necessary for every appropriate patient?

Why use more extensive fixation when less may suffice?

That question has guided our InSpan research.

We have studied biomechanics, fixation strength, and clinical outcomes.

Our publications include follow-up extending beyond five years.

The findings have encouraged surgeons exploring less invasive alternatives.

These physicians are innovators.

They evaluate the evidence and question established practices.

But innovators are a minority.

The early majority often determines broader clinical adoption.

And that majority is understandably harder to move.

So what moves surgeons: evidence or established habits?

I believe both influence adoption.

And that should concern anyone committed to scientific progress.

3. How Many More Papers Will It Take?

We have published research.

We have followed patients for years.

We have investigated the biomechanics.

We continue studying the clinical outcomes.

Yet the question remains.

When is enough data enough?

Should we publish another five papers?

Conduct another multicenter study?

Wait another decade?

Perhaps.

Rigorous comparative research and independent replication remain essential.

But scientific evidence does not automatically change surgical behavior.

And no single study should determine every patient's treatment.

I sometimes wonder whether we underestimate this challenge.

We can develop technologies faster than we change minds.

That is the paradox of medical innovation.

Our responsibility is to keep testing our assumptions.

Including our own.

If InSpan performs better for specific patients, demonstrate it.

If traditional fixation performs better, demonstrate that too.

Let the evidence decide.

Not tradition.

Not commercial influence.

Not professional conformity.

I invite spine surgeons to examine our InSpan publications.

I invite researchers to challenge and expand our findings.

And I invite patients to ask one important question.

What evidence supports the treatment you are recommending?

Read our InSpan research:

Follow our research as we continue building the evidence.

Patients deserve the treatment best supported by evidence.

Not simply the treatment their surgeon knows best.

Kingsley R Chin, MD MBA Board-Certified Orthopedic Spine Surgeon Professor of Orthopedics and Spine Surgery Chief Executive Officer, KIC Ventures Distinguished Fellow, North American Spine Society Fellow, American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page